bure961 wrote:
I do not completley understand what causes the IE in hrc to be 2-3- or a hrc4.
My question is if I am doing troubleshooting in a motor starter cabinet or mcc and the cabinet has a hrc 4 label on it can i open the cb and disconnect the load and work in the panel ? Will disconnecting the load before beginning work lower the IE ?
Actually yes disconnecting the load CAN lower the incident energy if it's an inductive or capacitive load such as a motor. When there is a fault, energy flows simultaneously from BOTH the line and from energy storage devices such as motors. So if you eliminate the motor the incident energy goes down. HOWEVER, the general approach is to look at a worst case scenario.
The easiest way to understand the CONCEPT is that if you have an arcing fault, the power flowing into the air gap where the arc is happening, proporitional APPROXIMATELY to volts times amps (it's not exact), is emitted as heat. The limit on the amount of current is the short circuit current of the system which is often thousands of amps. Cable and transformer impedances are generally what reduces this. The amount of damage caused by the heat depends on how long the arc occurs. And power multiplied by time is energy. Now the last factor here is that the energy is generally radiated in all directions so the farther you are away, the lower the amount of heat over an area of your skin. To give you a perspective, holding your hand in the flame over a disposable lighter for 1 second, 1 inch away is about 1 cal/cm^2.
If you want to reduce incident energy, either move farther away, speed up the circuit breakers or fuses (reduce time), or use smaller transformers (lower available fault current). The old trend of setting the protective systems as high as practical is dead. The current strategy is to set them as tightly as possible. Also, multiple smaller transformers and circuit breakers are a better strategy than putting in one large one. And installing equipment that is not maintainable (e.g. sealed breakers) is an effective strategy.